Below is a rewrite of my essay, "Growing Jade Plants." Does it give my readers enough guidance about its meaning?
GROWING JADE PLANTS
I started my jade plant collection twelve years ago at a family dinner. My mother, a devoted gardener, had grown a gaggle of jade plants and installed them in the dining room’s bay window long before her death a year earlier.
Her jade plants’ dark brown limbs and deep green fleshy leaves were outlined by the bright white of the ledge on which they rested. The largest plant stretched wider than the biggest platter my parents had ever displayed on their elegant dinner table. It captured my fancy with its wildly twisted tree-like branches reminiscent of a Japanese bonsai tree. I was also taken with the cluster of smaller plants, huddled closely as though seeking safety in the shadow of their mother plant. I missed my mother, who had always held out her arms to me.
But Mom had effectively lost her mother when Mom was twenty-two years old. In 1948, she made the long trip by ocean liner from Johannesburg, South Africa to the United States to visit relatives. The jade plant also is an emigrant. It, too, came from South Africa, like so many other robust succulents.
I carried my cutting home nestled in a bed of paper towels. Then I placed it in a paper cup filled with water and waited for roots to sprout.
Mom hadn’t planned to stay in the United States, but she didn’t even visit South Africa for more than thirty years after she arrived in this country. She married my father, whom she met at her aunt’s home, she bore two children, and she took pleasure in the garden outside the house I lived in from the end of first grade until I left for college. Perhaps she found solace there for her loss of her mother.
My mother tried to get me to help her in the garden, but I fled in horror the first day. An earthworm oozed into view shortly after I stuck my fingers into the soil. Boys at my elementary school threw dead earthworms at unwary girls when a rainstorm left them stranded atop the nubby blacktop. The first time that happened, I cringed, then ran for shelter in a teacher’s orbit. I wouldn’t willingly place myself near those creepy crawlers. However, as an adult, I was willing to take a chance on house plants in sterile potting soil.
I had rooted spider plants before, but never a jade. I anxiously watched the progress of my cutting. When it took root, I felt happy, as if I’d seen a baby grow into a healthy toddler against all odds. I pulled out my yellow plastic bucket of potting soil and the child-sized shovel with which I’d welcome my plant into its first pot.
The potting succeeded. At first the new buds of fat green leaves protruded delicately like the tip of a tongue. Then they pushed out more decisively. Before long, they reached high into the air like my mother’s roses twirling around a white wooden trellis outside our home’s back door.
My mom had done most of the outdoor work at home. Pruning roses and other shrubs couldn’t daunt a woman who wrestled a testy gas-powered lawnmower. She cut decisively and confidently.
I dithered before I took pruning shears to my child for the first time. I felt as if I was lopping off one of its limbs. But my jade plant came back with two new branches where one had been.
Once I felt confident that my plant’s regeneration wasn’t a freak of nature, I got hooked on growing more plants from cuttings. Now I’ve got about half a dozen plump green children, each throwing out branches. Like Mom, they were transplants, setting down roots far from home. Like me, they could set down roots even after getting cut off from Mom.
My success at rooting jade plants inspired me to start gardening outdoors. Now when I see worms, I smile because they’re aerating compost bins that feed my garden. Mom’s jade plants led me to a happier view of the world.
Ahh! Some wonderful moments in this essay. You’re developing your similes (e.g. “At first the new buds of fat green leaves protruded delicately like the tip of a tongue.”) quite nicely, and your description and details are sharp.
Some thoughts: I’m wondering where this essay would go if you included more reflection? Some lines that jumped out at me: “I missed my mother, who had always held out her arms to me.”
Was she deceased (I know the answer, but your readers don’t)? If yes, how long had she been gone when you started with the jade plants? How did she die? Did the two of you leave anything unsaid? Tell your readers more about this closeness you had with Mom. Was she your best friend? Did you share secrets? Was there a part of her that she kept roped off from you–and everyone else (her past, her hopes, her dreams as a child)?
Another line that struck me: “Perhaps she found solace there for her loss of her mother.”
Did she ever talk about this loss? If yes, what did she say? If not, why do you think she avoided it? Did her avoidance make her seem as if she was holding something back from you and others?
Did your mom really ever have roots here? Or do you think these roots were tenuous at best? Do you feel rooted to your world?
The ending seems to wrap up too nicely–few things wrap up that nicely in real life. While your mom’s love for gardening opened up a wonderful new world/hobby for you, it also left you reflective. Are your roots stronger than hers? Do you feel guilty that you have happiness that perhaps your mother didn’t have? Or ARE you your mother?
I think there’s some wonderful imagery here, and the plant metaphor works…but I’m wondering if you’re holding back. Again, great situation…now what’s the story?
Comment by fatcharlatan — February 21, 2007 @ 12:23 pm
Okay–I just reread–you DID answer in your lead about your mother’s death and the timing. The rest of my questions apply, though.
Comment by fatcharlatan — February 21, 2007 @ 12:24 pm
Thank you! These are very helpful questions.
Comment by Administrator — February 21, 2007 @ 1:06 pm
This sentence caught me off guard:
My mother, a devoted gardener, had grown a gaggle of jade plants and installed them in the dining room’s bay window long before her death a year earlier.
Is it your mother who died a year earlier? Am I confused, and not seeing something?
Comment by ptcakes — February 22, 2007 @ 1:54 pm
I can see that I need to be more direct about my mother’s death.
Maybe, “Awhile before her death one year earlier, my mother had grown a gaggle of jade plants and installed them in the dining room’s bay window.”
Or, should I omit “one year earlier”?
Comment by Administrator — February 22, 2007 @ 4:07 pm
My mother, a devoted gardener, had grown a gaggle of jade plants and installed them in the dining room’s bay window in the years before her death.
Of course, the phrase, in the years before her death, is almost unnecessary. Since she couldn’t have done it after she died.
Comment by ptcakes — February 22, 2007 @ 7:15 pm
Yes, but for the purpose of the essay you need to know that she’s dead. I guess I could try to fit that fact in elsewhere.
Comment by Administrator — February 22, 2007 @ 8:20 pm
I like this a lot, and I also agree with FC’s comments earlier. I’d like some more thoughts on the relationships explored here. But you have a beautiful framework for a great story.
Comment by writerbug — February 26, 2007 @ 1:18 pm